Jill L. Brown v. William Charles Payton

544 U.S. 133 · Decided March 22, 2005 · Supreme Court of the United States

At a glance

Jill L. Brown v. William Charles Payton was decided on March 22, 2005 by a vote of 5–3. The Court vacated the lower court's decision and remanded the case. Justice Anthony M. Kennedy wrote the opinion of the Court. SCDB classifies its main issue as “Cruel and unusual punishment, death penalty” in the Criminal Procedure area.

Read the opinion

• CourtListener (Free Law Project) — opinion text
• Library of Congress — official U.S. Reports scan

Case details

How the Justices voted

Did not participate: William H. Rehnquist.

Full case caption

Jill L. Brown, Warden v. William Charles Payton

SCDB identifiers: case 2004-032, docket 2004-032-01.

Related decisions

Other cases on “Cruel and unusual punishment, death penalty”

• Donald P. Roper v. Christopher SimmonsAltered precedentLaw held unconstitutional
  543 U.S. 551Decided March 1, 20055–4Anthony M. Kennedy
• Laroyce Lathair Smith v. Texas
  543 U.S. 37Decided November 15, 20047–2Per curiam
• Dora B. Schriro v. Robert Douglas Smith
  546 U.S. 6Decided October 17, 20059–0Per curiam
• Jill L. Brown v. Ronald L. Sanders
  546 U.S. 212Decided January 11, 20065–4Antonin Scalia
• Oregon v. Randy Lee Guzek
  546 U.S. 517Decided February 22, 20068–0Stephen G. Breyer
• Kansas v. Michael Lee Marsh
  548 U.S. 163Decided June 26, 20065–4Clarence Thomas

See all

Cases on the same legal provision: 28 U.S.C. §§ 2241–2255 (habeas corpus)

• Charles Russell Rhines v. Douglas Weber
  544 U.S. 269Decided March 30, 20059–0Sandra Day O'Connor
• Robert Johnson, Jr. v. United States
  544 U.S. 295Decided April 4, 20055–4David H. Souter
• John A. Pace v. David Diguglielmo
  544 U.S. 408Decided April 27, 20055–4William H. Rehnquist
• Ricky Bell v. Gary Bradford Cone
  543 U.S. 447Decided January 24, 20059–0Per curiam
• Thomas Joe Miller-El v. Doug Dretke
  545 U.S. 231Decided June 13, 20056–3David H. Souter
• Michael Donald Dodd v. United States
  545 U.S. 353Decided June 20, 20055–4Sandra Day O'Connor

Same Term, same area (Criminal Procedure)

• Laroyce Lathair Smith v. Texas
  543 U.S. 37Decided November 15, 20047–2Per curiam
• Gerald Devenpeck v. Jerome Anthony Alford
  543 U.S. 146Decided December 13, 20048–0Antonin Scalia
• Florida v. Joe Elton Nixon
  543 U.S. 175Decided December 13, 20048–0Stephen G. Breyer
• David Whitfield v. United States
  543 U.S. 209Decided January 11, 20059–0Sandra Day O'Connor
• United States v. Freddie J. BookerLaw held unconstitutional
  543 U.S. 220Decided January 12, 20055–4Stephen G. Breyer
• Illinois v. Roy I. Caballes
  543 U.S. 405Decided January 24, 20056–2John Paul Stevens

See all

Source: Supreme Court Database, 2026 Release 01 (data file dated September 8, 2026). Imported into CaseTrail November 5, 2026. Coverage: decisions from the 1946 through 2025 Terms. Methodology · Report an error